Showing posts with label BPR3. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BPR3. Show all posts

Friday, June 6, 2008

Cool observations of glacial earthquakes

ResearchBlogging.orgGlacial earthquakes have been one of the hot topics in seismology over the past few years. As they slide past asperities in the bedrock, certain glaciers emit long period seismic waves that can be detected by relatively distant seismic stations. These slip events are what we call glacial earthquakes.

Wiens et al. (2008) have recently published in Nature a set of beautiful observations of this phenomenon. They have put together information from regional seismic observations and a local GPS survey to constrain the nucleation, slip velocity and duration of glacial earthquakes occurring on the Whillans ice-field in West Antarctica.


They find that glacial earthquakes occur on this glacier twice a day, and seem to be triggered by tides in the Ross Sea. When the ice starts moving, it generates a seismic signal. Some minutes later, a second signal is generated when the moving ice hits the side of the glacier, and a third signal is generated when the ice hits the grounding line and stops moving.



The timing of these signals and the horizontal velocities measured by a temporary GPS network installed on the glacier give information on the amount of ice that moves in each event. Wiens et al. have estimated the energy released by the glacial earthquake to be equivalent to a M7 earthquake, only spread over the 20 minutes it takes the ice to stop moving.

For more publicly acessible information, read the early releases from ScientificBlogging and ScienceNOW.

Wiens, D.A., Anandakrishnan, S., Winberry, J.P., King, M.A. (2008). Simultaneous teleseismic and geodetic observations of the stick-slip motion of an Antarctic ice stream. Nature, 453(7196), 770-774. DOI: 10.1038/nature06990

Sunday, April 6, 2008

Using seismic waves to image Earth's internal structure

ResearchBlogging.org

Life on board the Marion Dufresne continues uneventfully. I am taking advantage of the relatively clement sea conditions to work on a manuscript due for submission soon, and to read some scientific literature.

Earth science is a frustrating subject at times. It seems the more we investigate the Earth, the less we understand how it works. Controversy is rife, generating much confusion in the minds of students and researchers alike. Questions like 'How do subduction zones work?' and 'Where does hotspot volcanism originate?' are still hotly debated at international conferences and in print. One of the ways we are trying to address these open questions is by striving for clearer and higher resolution images of the Earth's interior.

Romanowicz (2008) gives a good three-page summary of past progress and outstanding issues in the use of seismic waves for this type of imaging.

To address these controversies, seismology has been brought to bear to image Earth's deep interior. From the construction of accurate models of Earth's one-dimensional radial structure to the current models of its three-dimensional structure, progress in seismic imaging has gone hand in hand with improvements in the design of seismic sensors, the capacity to record digitally increasingly massive quantities of data, theoretical progress in handling seismic-wave propagation through complex three-dimensional media and the development of powerful computers for simulating seismic waves and for the inversion of large matrices.
We are now at a point where there is a certain consensus regarding the long wavelength heterogeneities within the Earth. The next steps according to Romanowicz should be
characterizing the sharpness or fuzziness of the boundaries of the heterogeneous structures deep inside the planet, and detecting and mapping small-scale heterogeneity [...] This will mean extracting more information from seismograms than has traditionally been done.
Romanowicz goes on to describe some of the recent advances that are already leading to improvements in tomographic imaging techniques, including first order scattering theory, spectral element wavefield simulation methods and the extraction of structural information from the cross-correlation of noise records.

The problem of data coverage still remains:
A significant challenge is the limited distribution of seismic-wave sources and receivers. Ideally, one would want to sample the volume of Earth uniformly. But unlike other disciplines that use imaging, such as medical tomography or petroleum exploration, earthquake seismologists cannot optimize their experimental geometry.

Here we return the main theme of the last few research blogging posts: the need to obtain more raw data and to exploit them more fully to improve the imaging of Earth's interior.

Quoted text reprinted by permission from Macmillan Publishers Ltd: Nature, copyright (2008).

References

Romanowicz, B. (2008). Using seismic waves to image Earth's internal structure. Nature, 451(7176), 266-268. DOI: 10.1038/nature06583

Monday, March 24, 2008

Can better physics guarantee better tomographic models?

ResearchBlogging.orgOne of the key elements in discussing an inverse problem such as seismic tomography is the quality of the forward theory. The better the forward theory, the better synthetic data can be predicted from physical model parameters, and hence the better the solution to the inverse problem, right?

Unfortunately the issue is not so simple. Trampert & Spetzler (2006) come to the dual conclusions that better physics (in the form a finite-frequency formulation of the sensitivity kernels of seismic wave measurements) is a necessary but not sufficient condition for improvement of tomographic models, and that the null-space (due to uneven or insufficient data coverage) is currently too large to permit the improvements in resolution that better physics could provide.

Despite finite-frequency kernels being more accurate than the approximate sensitivity formulations of ray-theory, models constructed from either theory are statistically similar, i.e. one cannot construct a finite-frequency model (with a given data fit and horizontal resolution) which cannot also be obtained from ray theory by changing the regularization damping of the inversion accordingly. Regularization dominates the significant aspects of tomographic models, and affects both finite-frequency models and ray-theory models similarly. Data error propagation is worse for finite-frequency kernels, but given the large influence of regularization, this is a minor problem.

The authors maintain that in order to increase the resolution of tomographic inversions, we have to remove the ill posedness in the inverse problem (an ill posed inverse problem has more degrees of freedom than can be constrained by the available data) by increasing and/or homogenizing data coverage. I agree whole-heartedly with this statement! What can be done?

(1) The current distribution of seismic stations is in-homogeneous (see figure at bottom of post showing all FDSN seismic stations), and is limited by the accessibility of suitable installation sites. We should attempt to homogenize the distribution of seismic stations by installing more instruments in currently inaccessible locations such as the sea-floor (ocean-bottom seismometers) and my personal favorite, Antarctica. This solution requires lots of time, effort and a high level of funding that is becoming more and more difficult to obtain.

(2) So far we only use very little information from the complete seismogram (first arrival times of a few main waves, or the dispersion characteristics of surface waves). We should use more of the information available from the complete seismogram, given that modern adjoint methods have made it possible to associate a complete sensitivity kernel to each measurable wiggle in a seismogram. This solution is technically feasible given enough computing power and the development of new tools to automate the data selection and measurement processes.



References

Trampert, J., Spetzler, J. (2006). Surface wave tomography: finite-frequency effects lost in the null space. Geophysical Journal International, 164(2), 394-400. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-246X.2006.02864.x

-----
Keep up to date with the latest developments at http://sismordia.blogspot.com

Sunday, March 23, 2008

High-performance computing: a revolution in seismic tomography?

ResearchBlogging.orgSeismic tomography - the process of making 3D images of the interior of the Earth from the information contained in seismograms - has in recent times become central to the debate about a number of controversial issues to do with the internal workings of the Earth, from the depths reached by subducted material, to the origin of mantle plumes, to the structure of the innermost inner core.

Many of these controversies stem in no small part from the lack of similarity between different tomographic images at small spatial wavelengths. It is evident to most tomographers that more needs to be done to improve the resolution of tomographic studies. Boschi et al. (2007) set out to discuss the role that may be played by high-performance computing in such an improvement.

The paper starts out with a useful and brief discussion of those factors that are currently limiting tomographic solution. These are : (i) the geographic coverage of the seismic observations being input into the tomographic inversions; (ii) the resolving power of the parameterization used for the inversions themselves; (iii) the accuracy of the theoretical formulations, i.e. the equations that relate seismic observations to the Earth parameters that are being inverted for.

In recent years, there has been a lot of progress on the theoretical side (point iii), and we have learned more about the sensitivity of seismic waves to heterogeneities in Earth structure. Although differences do exist between tomographic models made using the newer theories (finite-frequency models) and those made using the older approximate theories (ray-theory models), these differences do not seem to be as important as those caused by data coverage and parameterization.

Parameterization density (point ii) defines the size of the inverse problem to be solved, with denser parameterizations being required for better resolving power (if the data can indeed constrain the greater number of degrees of freedom implied by all these parameters). Increases in parameterization density lead to the need for larger computers (or greater number of nodes in parallel computing machines). These needs are by and large being met by advances in both desktop PC technologies and high-power computing facilities.

The authors infer that the main factor limiting tomographic resolution is data coverage (point i), which is very inhomogenous due to the limited geographic distribution of earthquakes (they are concentrated mainly at the boundaries often tectonic plates) and of stations (located mostly on land, while two-thirds of the Earth's surface lies under water). They surmise that in the absence of uniform station coverage, the main challenge for tomographers is to establish appropriate parameterization / regularization criteria to damp instabilities in the inversions caused by lack of data, without obscuring valuable information.

The rest of the paper describes two growingly popular techniques (statistical information criteria and adjoint methods), and calculates the computational cost if they were to be used for a global tomographic study. The conclusion reached is that high performance computing is indeed required in order to implement these techniques on a global scale.

The question I ask in the title of this post - whether the implementation of high-performance computing tomographic techniques will bring about a revolution in our ability to image the interior of the Earth - is not really answered in this paper. It is probably too early to say. I find, however, that the authors have skimmed over the data-coverage problem too quickly.

Although it is true that the geographical distribution of earthquakes is fixed and that the distribution of seismic stations is unlikely to change dramatically over the next decade, I believe more can be done with the currently available data. Most tomographic inversions use only a small fraction of the information contained in the seismograms.

A greater use of full waveform data, combined with the accurate calculation of their sensitivity, is likely to fill in many of the regions that are currently under-sampled and hence poorly resolved in tomographic models. As data-coverage seems to be the most severe limiting factor to the resolution of seismic tomography, might not relatively minor increases in the exploitation of the information contained in each seismogram lead to significant improvements to tomographic images?

Following is one of the figures of a paper I am working on, which describes a new strategy for selecting data windows on seismograms in a way that is appropriate for the latest generation of tomographic techniques. One of the considerations that went into the development of this strategy was to enable the use of as much of the information contained within the seismogram as possible. I'll divulge more about how this all works once the paper has been submitted.



References

BOSCHI, L., AMPUERO, J., PETER, D., MAI, P., SOLDATI, G., GIARDINI, D. (2007). Petascale computing and resolution in global seismic tomography. Physics of The Earth and Planetary Interiors, 163(1-4), 245-250. DOI: 10.1016/j.pepi.2007.02.011


-----
Keep up to date with the latest developments at http://sismordia.blogspot.com

Monday, August 27, 2007

Peer review icon contest

Ten days ago I wrote about an initiative to standardize and aggregate posting on peer reviewed research in all subjects. This initiative has now developed into a fledgling organization called BPR3 - Bloggers for Peer Review Research Reporting.

There has been a lot of activity over at BPR3, discussing working definitions of peer-review, the requirements for an icon to specifically indicate that a post is about peer-reviewed research, the practicalities of aggregation of such posts.

Now for the latest: the BPR3 Icon Contest :

Bloggers for Peer-Reviewed Research Reporting is pleased to announce its contest for designing the icon that will represent the organization and its mission on academic blogs world-wide.

Contest participants will design a universal icon that everyone can use on their blog posts whenever the post is a serious commentary about a paper published in a peer-reviewed journal, and not just a link to a press release or media commentary.

Eventually these posts will be collected on BPR3.org, so anyone can find the most thoughtful blog posts on the internet, discussing serious research, not just media hype.

The deadline for submissions is September 10th. All submissions are welcome, but please read the icon specifications and contest rules on this post before rushing off to your design table.

Sunday, August 19, 2007

Antarctic history revealed by shear wave splitting

Blogging on Peer-Reviewed Research
Antarctica is a patchwork of different blocs, which have come together and split apart a number of times before forming the continent as we know it today. The history of this coming and going is written in the fabric of the Antarctic lithosphere, and can be read using standard seismological techniques.

One such technique is shear wave splitting, the investigation of shear wave birefringence through the upper mantle that has been rendered anisotropic by the accumulated effect of millions of years of tectonic processes. By measuring the anisotropy via shear wave splitting, we can attempt to unravel this tectonic history.

Bayer et al. (2007) present results of shear wave splitting measurements carried out on permanent and temporary seismic stations in Dronning Maud Land, Antarctica. They show that the anisotropy varies strongly with position, indicating the presence of distinct lithospheric blocs, separated by a suture that probably cuts through the whole lithosphere.

The anisotropy they find is not consistent with current plate motion, but in general follows the strike of magnetic anomalies, indicating that the crust and mantle were strongly coupled during the major tectonic episodes by which the Antarctic continent was assembled.

At near coastal stations this study agrees with previous research in finding evidence for two superposed layers of seismic anisotropy. The upper layer is consistent with local crustal magnetic anomalies. The lower layer is consistent with the first rifting stages of the Gondwana super-continent, when South Africa separated from the Antarctic continent.

In short, the seismic anisotropy found by shear wave splitting in Donning Maud Land strongly supports a succession of continental collisions, lithospheric extension and fragmentation. As the seismic experiments planned for the International Polar Year take place, there will be data from more locations in Antarctica, and more of the jigsaw puzzle of this frozen continent will fall into place.

References

Bayer, B., Muller, C., Eaton, D.W., Jokat, W. (2007). Seismic anisotropy beneath Dronning Maud Land, Antarctica, revealed by shear wave splitting. Geophysical Journal International, 171(1), 339-351. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-246X.2007.03519.x

-----
Keep up to date with the latest developments at http://sismordia.blogspot.com

Saturday, August 18, 2007

Overwintering in Antarctica - good for one's health?

Blogging on Peer-Reviewed ResearchIt has always seemed to me that overwintering in Antarctica would be a fascinating experience, albeit not one I would engage in lightly if at all. I would not consider myself psychologically stable enough to endure the isolation. In any case, I would never have thought it could be beneficial to one's psychological health.

This article in Le Figaro online (which I only found thanks to a reference in a mountaineering blog of all places) refers to a recent article in The Lancet (Palinkas & Suedfeld, 2007) on the subject of the consequences of living for long periods of time in the polar regions.

It seems from this study, which includes amongst other measures of "health" the examination of diaries or logs written by the overwintering team themselves, that the physiological and psychological reactions to the environment are by no means only detrimental.

Of course there is an increased risk of accidents tied the the climactic conditions, and also some derailment of thyroid function and of the internal body clock. These last tend to cause perturbed sleep patterns, a loss of intellectual prowess and memory, and increased irritability that can lead to tensions and conflicts, all of which can cause depression.

However, the authors of the study underline that there are also positive side effects, notably the joy and self confidence that are a direct consequence of living in these difficult conditions and surmounting the difficulties as they come. The authors also found in the diaries many references to the beauty and grandeur of the environment, to the camaraderie and support of the entire team, and to the strong emotions generated by facing and surmounting the challenges the environment brings. It is also significant that many of those who overwinter once in Antarctica, apply to do so again.

All this rings true to me, although I have not, and probably never will, overwinter anywhere. Not only because I have been reading a number of web-logs of current and past overwinterers, but also because I have felt the same emotions myself, the same camaraderie, joy and self confidence, during summer campaigns in the sub-Antarctic. There is a saying in our group at the lab :

"The more difficult the campaign is, the better the memories when you surmount the difficulties, and the sooner you want to go back!."


References

L. Palinkas & P. Suedfeld, 2007. Psychological effects of polar expeditions, The Lancet, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(07)61056-3


-----
Keep up to date with the latest developments at http://sismordia.blogspot.com

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

Posts on peer-reviewed research

Writing about peer reviewed research is something most reputable scientific bloggers engage in at some time or another. I feel it may be a good way to make rather technical scientific results more palatable to the interested layman, and put more of these results in the public domain.

Other advantages may be to bring more papers to the attention of over-worked colleagues, and provide the blogger with a platform to more or less systematically analyze and summarize the papers he or she is reading.

There is an interesting discussion on this subject at Cognitive Daily. The suggestion is to create a logo or badge that would signify "This post is about peer reviewed research", and also to set up a web-site which references all such peer-review posts. The objectives of this movement seem to be:

  1. to create a consistent way to alert readers about the peer-reviewed nature of the subject being covered in the post they are reading;
  2. to bring together in a single site references to all these posts;
  3. give bloggers kudos for their commitment to high quality science posts.
Personally, I think a peer-reviewed research label is an excellent idea, and would be more than willing (time permitting of course) to write peer-review posts. Writing succinctly and clearly about other people's research will in any case be excellent practice for writing succinctly and clearly about my own!

-----
Keep up to date with the latest developments at http://sismordia.blogspot.com